Miracles vs. Coincidence: A Biblical Test for Divine Intervention

A shower-voice encounter, an FBI raid, and a test for telling real miracles from chance.

One man calculates the odds that a strange inner voice and a sudden industry shutdown were more than mere chance, and asks what you would conclude.

Editor’s note – The question the author poses here is bigger than one man’s Lenten poker fast. If the God of Scripture is real and near, He can still interrupt an ordinary Tuesday with a message you did not ask for and could not have staged. The author’s account of a voice, a fast, and an FBI raid he never saw coming is worth setting alongside modern skepticism’s dismissal of the miraculous before it has even looked at the evidence. We are publishing it not because every reader will reach his conclusion, but because the questions he raises deserve an honest hearing.

What’s at Stake in the Miracle Debate

The stakes are high when it comes to claims of miracles.

If an actual miracle is possible, it means that science is not the ultimate authority on truth. It means science is a wonderful tool to understand the natural realm, but that there is a reality that exists outside the realm of scientific exploration.

Something supernatural.

Illustration of scientific instruments beside a starry sky representing natural and supernatural realms
Science: a useful tool or the ultimate arbiter of reality? (AI)

And if we’re dealing with a supernatural world, it means entities like angels and demons may be real. And most disconcerting of all (for some), the existence of the supernatural would mean the idea of a God who has a claim on your life can no longer be dismissed.

Suffice it to say, there is plenty of motivation to deny the miraculous.

In many ways, it’s also a logical posture to take towards life.

Skepticism is Not Unreasonable

Natural laws have a solid track record of explaining most of the events we experience in life.

So a skeptic isn’t being unreasonable to look for strong evidence.

What is irrational is an unwillingness to consider that one might be in error when the evidence demands it.

And that’s what happens when refuting an alleged miracle becomes an exercise in circular reasoning that refuses to engage with the actual data.

Philosopher and skeptic David Hume came up with his own famous argument that “proves” no one should ever seriously consider any miraculous claim.¹

It basically works like this: “miracles are not possible, therefore we should not ever consider that a miracle could have occurred.” It’s a recipe for refusing to open a closed mind.

Illustration of a person covering their eyes to avoid looking at data that contradicts their belief
I won’t consider the data if I don’t like the data (AI)

Of course, those who believe in miracles are prone to error as well. The human brain is susceptible to aggressive pattern recognition and confirmation bias.

That’s why we all need to be aware of the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.

Editor’s note – Hume’s argument against miracles is popular precisely because it never has to examine a single case. Define the miraculous out of existence in advance, and no evidence can ever count against you. That is not scholarship; it is a locked door with the light left on so it looks like someone checked.

The Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy

The Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy is a type of confirmation bias.

Imagine a not-so-sharpshooting Texan who sprays bullets all over the side of a barn.

After the shooting is complete, he then draws the bullseye around the closest grouping of bullet holes and claims that’s where he was aiming for the whole time.

In other words, you can find miracles by considering the data that suits your narrative and ignoring the data that doesn’t fit.

Illustration of a target painted around a cluster of bullet holes on a barn wall
Yee-haw, take a look at that! (AI)

When combined with the truly massive number of unique events that take place each day, a miracle-seeker armed with their paintbrush is going to find a miracle somewhere.

But it doesn’t have to be that way.

Draw the Bullseye First

There is a simple way to control for the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.

Establish a highly precise and unlikely bullseye before the shooting begins.

If those clear and unlikely data points are in place before the “miraculous” event there is a clear link to evaluate whether we’re in the territory of miracles or coincidence.

This is why one mark of a true prophet in the Bible was predicting what was going to take place in the future and then actually seeing those circumstances come to pass.

Illustration of an ancient scroll and a compass representing a prophetic prediction later fulfilled

Moses gives precisely this instruction from God to the Israelites in Deuteronomy 18.

You may say to yourselves, "How can we know when a message has not been spoken by the Lord?" If what a prophet proclaims in the name of the Lord does not take place or come true, that is a message the Lord has not spoken. That prophet has spoken presumptuously, so do not be alarmed. [Deuteronomy 18:21-22]

Linking unlikely “pre-event data” with equally unlikely “post event data” is one of the reasons I now believe a miracle took place in my life nearly sixteen years ago.

You can decide for yourself what seems most reasonable to you.

Editor’s note – Deuteronomy 18 sets a genuinely dangerous bar for a prophet: get it wrong even once and you were never speaking for the Lord. That standard cuts against sloppy claims of divine speech as much as it cuts against reflexive unbelief. It is the same standard the author is about to apply to his own story, which is a more honest approach than most miracle claims receive, from believers or skeptics.

A Miraculous Case Study

The full story is here, but the main elements begin this way:

I was taking a shower when I “heard” a thought / voice that wasn’t mine speak inside my head.

This thought / voice urged me to give up poker for Lent, which was just about to begin.

I loved poker (correction: was addicted to poker) and I had never participated in Lent or even thought of the idea (too Catholic!).

And I certainly had never before heard an unknown voice speaking to me from my mind.

For all these reasons I tried to reject the thought / voice and return to what I “knew” to be reality. But it was frustratingly persistent.

And eventually my analyst brain began to consider that maybe the “impossible” was happening. Could it actually be that God was communicating to me?

So I stood in the shower and debated whether I was losing my mind or whether God had chosen to show up in my life in a whole new way.

I decided I was not insane. And therefore, as unlikely as it might be, it was more likely the “voice” was actually God.

And so I begrudgingly agreed to the Lent poker prohibition and then began waiting impatiently for Easter to come so I could play poker again.

But something happened shortly before Easter that has come to be known as “Poker’s Black Friday.”

On April 15, 2011, a series of FBI raids at the biggest online offshore poker sites meant that I lost access to my online accounts and all my money. I never again played online competitive poker (or competitive poker anywhere, for that matter).

Illustration of a shocked man staring at a laptop screen showing a locked poker account
That was quite a surprise (AI)

As the shock of my lost accounts settled in, my first thought was to be deeply angry at God. I had listened to His voice and this was how He repaid me?!

But my conscious anger quickly transitioned to a subconscious resolution to try and forget about the whole thing. Because the implications were too uncomfortable. I didn’t like the idea of a personal God who could break in and interrupt my life, and so I stuffed down the truth.

I stayed in that place for years.

Now I know that God is truly real and truly good and that He can do impossible things like this. So my brain is free to actually run a more honest comparison to test this alleged miracle.

Let’s look at two options for what really happened.

Option A: Miracle

I didn’t know it while I was taking that shower, but God was drawing the bullseye with a once in a lifetime event that defied all my ideas about reality:

A voice that I believed to be God had spoken.

The timing of the message was just before the beginning of Lent.

The content of the message was about Lent and giving up poker.

This was directly followed by another unprecedented event: the one and only industry-wide crackdown on online poker that took place shortly before the conclusion of Lent.

The bullseye was hit.

To be clear, this view does not claim God caused the poker shutdown because I listened to His voice. Rather, God knew the shutdown was coming. And He gave me the opportunity to voluntarily step away from my addiction at the perfect time.

My insatiable craving for poker was suddenly gone. Another miracle. In the years to follow God eventually began to show me that He is personally real and that (the biggest shock!) He actually loves people like me and you.

And because He loves me, He wants to remove harmful things from my life (like a growing addiction to poker) and guide me along paths that I never would have chosen on my own.

God is real. Miracles can happen. This was divine intervention.

Editor’s note – Notice what the author does not claim: he does not say God caused the FBI to act. He says God knew what was coming and used the timing to call him out of an addiction. That is a meaningful distinction, and one worth remembering the next time someone dismisses providence as mere fatalism.

Option B: Coincidence

The alternative explanation is that this was explainable in a naturalistic way.

I asked an AI tool to come up with its best explanation for what happened without involving God.

“A naturalistic explanation would be that some unconscious process generated the thought without my conscious awareness, causing an internally generated thought to feel foreign or externally sourced. Then came an extraordinary coincidence: the FBI’s Black Friday crackdown shut down the major online poker sites shortly before Easter, exactly when I had expected to resume playing. But this explanation still has to account for the unusual combination of details — the unexpected appearance of Lent despite my rejection of it, the specific focus on poker, the unprecedented sense that God was speaking, the timing of the apparent message before Black Friday, and the disappearance of the addiction afterward.”

The challenge for this scenario is that it has to account for two astronomical coincidences that are immune from the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy because there is both a prediction and a fulfillment.

This isn’t like getting struck by lightning twice. It’s like getting struck by lightning with a message that says, “you’re going to get struck by lightning again in 5 weeks” — and then having that actually happen.

Let’s try some rough coincidence math.

If two events are genuinely independent of each other, the probability that both occur is the product of their individual probabilities.

On the day I “heard” the voice, I had been alive about 10,220 days. Such a thing had taken place on precisely one of those days. In other words, such an event — with its very precise message about Lent and poker — took place on 0.010% of all my days on earth.

Lightning strike two was the industry shutdown.

Online poker has existed since 1997. Between then and “Poker’s Black Friday” was about 5,217 days. If it was all random, the odds of an industry-wide crackdown was a 0.019% likelihood event. If we multiply 0.010% by 0.019% we get 0.00000187%. Or something that is a 1 in 53,000,000 event.

Illustration of dice and probability charts representing the astronomical odds of two rare events coinciding

Those are long odds.

And they get longer when we consider how hard it is for online poker addicts to quit.

According to Bluesky Counseling, 90% of gambling addicts who attempt to quit will relapse.²

I didn’t have a relapse. Instead, the unrelenting urge that fed hours of online poker each night had vanished completely. I was initially mad at God about my freedom, but I was nonetheless free.

That means my story with successfully quitting on my first attempt was a 1 in 10 prospect if it were sheer chance. Making the 1 in 53,000,000 odds more like 1 in half a billion.

Your Worldview Determines Your View of Reality

If the story is true, it is hard to pin as a coincidence.

But that’s exactly what I had decided back then even though I knew the story was true. Just a coincidence. Move along. Nothing to see here.

I didn’t think about it because I didn’t want to think about it.

It was only after other unexplainable “coincidences” (like Jesus saving me from a long term porn addiction) happened years later that I began to see a clearer picture. The evidence became whelming and I began to see that God actually knows me and loves me, despite my many offenses against Him.³

Of course, I still have an analytical brain and I still remember what it’s like to have a view of the world that doesn’t consider the possibility of a good God who can do miracles.

If you’re curious what that looks like, check out the “miracle version” compared to the “non-miracle version” of the same set of circumstances surrounding the birth of our second child.

But more important than anything about my life is what you think for your own life.

Are you open to the idea of miracles or not? Is there anything at all that could change your mind? And if the answer is no, what do you think is really keeping you from having an open mind?

1: Hume’s Theorem Concerning Miracles: https://davidhume.org/scholarship/papers/millican/1993_Miracles.pdf

2: Gambling Addiction: Can a Gambler Ever Stop? https://blueskycounselingomaha.com/can-a-gambler-stop-gambling-addiction/

3: Perhaps it is precisely because I am stubborn and a slow learner that God has intervened so directly. Thank you, Jesus.

A Word from the Editor
Whether or not you find the poker story convincing, the deeper issue the author raises is the one Jesus put to His own generation: what would actually change your mind? Scripture warns that a hardened heart can watch the dead raised and still ask for one more sign (Luke 16:31). The God who spoke through prophets and confirmed His word before it happened is still able to interrupt a life today. The real question is not whether the evidence is sufficient, but whether we are willing to follow wherever it leads.


Salvation – Eternal Life in Less Than 150 Words

Distributed by – BCWorldview.org

Core Statement of Belief


Editor Comment: Thank you for laying out such a carefully reasoned, personal account of how God can interrupt an ordinary life with something only He could have timed.

This article appeared on Medium and is reprinted with modifications and by permission.

3 COMMENTS

guest

3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
RELATED ARTICLES

Recent Articles