The phrase “Hate the sin, love the sinner” is a popular expression in evangelical circles. It’s often said with the best intentions, aiming to highlight the depth of God’s love and His ability to separate a person from their sinful actions. However, while this sentiment is well-meaning, it’s essential to evaluate its theological soundness in light of Scripture.

The Word of God provides profound insights into how He perceives sin and sinners. In Ephesians 2, the Apostle Paul reminds us that sinful humanity, in its natural state, is under God’s wrath and deserving of condemnation. Romans 5 further underscores this reality, describing humanity as natural enemies of God. These passages highlight a key truth: without divine intervention, every person is destined for judgment.

This reality challenges the idea that God makes a clear-cut distinction between sin and sinner. According to Scripture, sin is not merely an action that can be isolated from the person committing it. Instead, sin is intrinsic to the human condition. As modern theologian R.C. Sproul famously put it, “We are not sinners because we sin; we sin because we are sinners.” This perspective reveals that sin is deeply ingrained in our nature, not just our behavior.

God’s Wrath and Mercy

Recognizing this, it becomes clear that God’s relationship with sinners is complex. While God’s holiness demands justice against sin, His love provides a path to redemption. The tension between these two realities is resolved in the gospel. God, in His mercy, chooses to love sinners — not because they are deserving, but because of His gracious nature.

This love is not a passive feeling but an active decision to cover humanity’s sinful condition. Through Christ’s sacrificial work, God demonstrates a love that is both longsuffering and merciful. He does not overlook sin; instead, He forgives it by taking its penalty upon Himself. In this way, God redeems both the sinner and forgives their sins.

A Unified Process

It’s crucial to understand that God’s work of salvation addresses both the sinner and their sins simultaneously. These aspects cannot be separated. By forgiving sins, God transforms sinners’ hearts, reconciling them to Himself. His love is both restorative and redemptive, ensuring that sin no longer defines those who trust in Him.

Conclusion

The idea of “hating the sin but loving the sinner” risks oversimplifying the profound truth of God’s relationship with humanity. The Bible presents a more nuanced view, where God’s justice and love are inseparably intertwined. He hates sin and judges it, but He also extends His love and mercy to sinners, offering them redemption through Christ.

As believers, we are called to reflect this balance in our own lives: to hate sin as God does, while demonstrating His love and grace to those trapped in it. This perspective not only honors God’s holiness but also highlights the transformative power of His love in a world desperate for redemption.