Editor’s note – Deconstruction stories usually get told one of two ways online: as a pure intellectual awakening, or as pure institutional failure. Zack Duncan’s piece sits in neither camp. He pulls specific testimonies from a deconstruction community and asks an honest, uncomfortable question: when doubt and real pain show up together, which one is actually driving the conclusion? We’re running this piece because that distinction matters pastorally, not just academically. Zack also turns the same question on the church itself, and on his own history with disappointment and silence from God – which is part of why this piece earns a hearing rather than a dismissal.
The Journey of Faith Goes in 2 Directions
We looked last week at Christian deconstruction and the three different places it can lead.
For the person who takes their questions, their frustrations, and their doubts to God, the path ultimately leads towards reconstruction. God can deal with doubt.
But without God in the conversation, the path leads towards deconversion.
Following Jesus is a journey.
He told His followers to pick up their crosses and to follow Him.
A Protestant Christian might call this the path of sanctification, while an Orthodox believer would call it theosis. But whatever the name and theological framing, this is the grand adventure of the Christian life.
It is the process of slowly being transformed, through God’s grace and the power of the Holy Spirit, more and more into the image of Christ.
Yet some turn around and walk the other way.
Instead of learning to trust, obey, and worship God above all else, there is a path that trusts the self above God and ultimately leads to the rejection of God.
Sometimes that happens passively as a childhood faith erodes over time. And sometimes it is an intentional brick-by-brick dismantling of old faith structures.
The Work of Intentional Deconversion
Below is a comment on the r/Deconstruction subreddit from someone doing this kind of purposeful demolition.
It’s clear that the work of deconstruction can feel difficult. As this commenter shows, it can take real effort to grow in disbelief.

We see that this person no longer believes in the God of the Bible…but still struggles with the Bible.
She still wonders, for example, why the accounts of the plagues were first written down and why they persisted for thousands of years. What’s the compelling counter narrative if these stories aren’t actually true?
This is where her church comes in. It assists her on her deconstruction journey by studying the Bible through the lens of discrediting it as a trustworthy source.

After two years at the church, she’s now nearly comfortable enough to be ready to “graduate” to a complete erosion of trust in the Bible and a final exit from the church.
Those going through deconstruction often say the catalyst for their deconstruction process was Christianity’s failure to answer their doubts.
I agree this can be true. There are many intelligent atheists in the world. But pondering the full comment shows there can be another motive at work.
Motives Can Drive Belief
This individual’s deconstruction decision doesn’t seem to spring primarily from holes she’s poked in the Bible or her doubts about the historicity of Jesus. On the contrary, this individual is actually looking to her church to bolster her reasons not to believe.
But her intentions to disbelieve are strong, despite her lingering questions.
After all, if she had a completely impartial mindset regarding those plagues, she might be studying an ancient document on display at the Dutch National Museum of Antiquities called the Ipuwer Papyrus.
It’s an argued over Egyptian perspective of plague-like devastation that tracks rather closely with the Biblical plagues as recorded in Exodus. While this is a fiercely debated view, it is nonetheless available evidence that lends credence to a historical Exodus.
But that doesn’t appear to be in view for her.
Why not? What else drives the motivation to disbelieve?
I believe we get a clue about what else is behind this deconstruction decision in the comment about the small groups focused on religious trauma.

For all the legitimate intellectual doubts of Christianity, there can sometimes be a deeper root beneath a purely academic critique.
And that root can be painful.
Editor’s note – This is the harder diagnosis to make, and Zack Duncan makes it carefully: not that every doubter is secretly motivated to disbelieve, but that some are, and the evidence they would need to look past is available for anyone willing to look. The Ipuwer Papyrus reference is a good example – it’s debated, but it exists, and a purely academic search for truth would at least weigh it. That gap is worth noticing before assuming every deconstruction story is purely intellectual.
Emotional Pain Can Drive Deconversion
If we look at other comments in the same subreddit we see more hints of the pain that can lead to a rejection of Christianity.
These people were all responding to the question of what they found most surprising after their deconversion.
This person reflects on decentering from a “fear-based thought system.”

It’s not a stretch to infer that the Christian faith had been a source of fear and anxiety for this person.
What a sobering realization for those of us who are Christians.
These do not seem to be the words of someone who was taught not only about the awesome holiness of a righteous God, but also about the extravagant love of a good Father who runs out to meet the Prodigal Son. They do not seem to be the words of someone who was surrounded by a Christian community consistently modeling God’s faithful, sacrificial, and perpetually-forgiving love.
The source of pain for this next individual took the form of a broken marriage in the home.

This is heartbreaking.
One can imagine how difficult it is to see oneself as a beloved child of a constant and faithful Heavenly Father, when earthly parents aren’t modeling the same.
Much could be said about the anguish that can come from such a fracture, but for our purposes today let’s look specifically at the link between the painful circumstances and the disbelief:
- The intellectual doubts began when the divorce took place.
- Doubts increased when mom went through psychosis.
- This person entered adulthood feeling “lost.” That’s when issues and contradictions in the Christian faith and in Christ followers become more visible.
The order of events matters. The pain and suffering was what led to intellectual doubts and eventual deconversion.
This isn’t to minimize the suffering, but to point out the link between the doubts and the distressing circumstances.
Why?
Feelings are Real, Yet Not Reliable
Psychologist Daniel Kahneman showed the human brain relies on both emotional processing and logical reasoning when it comes to decision making.
He called the former System 1 thinking and the latter System 2 thinking.
System 2 is deliberate, logical, and resource intensive for our brains. It’s also much better at identifying inconsistencies and making sound conclusions.
System 1 is automatic, fast, and makes intuitive leaps. It can be a great supplement when working in tandem with System 2.¹
It can also be an unreliable decision-making shortcut when we rely on it too much. Which we tend to do when our brains are overloaded and resource constrained.

This is why McDonald’s spends money to tell you that your desire for a McChicken is evidence that you “deserve” one. It persuades the brain operating primarily on emotional System 1 thinking, while it’s utterly nonsensical to System 2 analysis.
In healthy decision making, both systems function simultaneously.
System 2 audits and controls the rapid fire judgements that System 1 makes. But in a stressed, fatigued, and overloaded brain, there are insufficient mental resources to keep System 2 running, and System 1 can take over.
And when that happens, we can see how a fatigued person in sustained emotional pain might be persuaded by an unstated argument like this: If Christianity feels bad, it must be bad.
We know that’s not a logical way to think. We know it flies in the face of time tested aphorisms like these:
- “Feelings are great servants, but terrible masters.”
- “Smooth seas do not make skillful sailors.”
- “Comfort is the enemy of progress.”
But we also know that an overtaxed brain can be prone to believing something that feels true when it’s not actually true.
Editor’s note – The System 1 and System 2 framework is a useful tool, not a final word. It explains how an exhausted, grieving mind can mistake a strong feeling for a settled fact. It does not explain away the pain itself, and Zack Duncan is careful not to use it that way – the goal here is honesty about how we reason, not a way to dismiss anyone’s suffering.
Is Belief in God Like Belief in Santa?
We can spot an example of something that feels true yet isn’t when we look further in the same subreddit.
For this former Christian, belief in God now feels so “obviously” silly that it is akin to belief in Santa Claus.

The commenter is not wrong to say it “legitimately feels” like belief in God is akin to belief in Kris Kringle.
Such a sentiment may indeed feel persuasive to System 1 thinking. But it only takes two questions to show it doesn’t pass muster for the brain also employing a logical System 2 approach.
- Question 1: Is it true that some people with genius-level intelligence like Blaise Pascal, Francis Collins, and C.S. Lewis either maintained faith in God for their entire lives or made a conscious decision to convert to Christianity from atheism?
- Question 2: Did any of those highly intelligent former atheists who converted to Christianity also adopt a belief in Santa Claus at the same time?

The answer to question 1 is clearly “yes” — just as the answer to question 2 is obviously “no.”
Which means what this commenter “legitimately feels” to be obvious isn’t not in fact obvious at all.
Editor’s note – Pascal, Collins, and Lewis do not settle the question of God’s existence by themselves. What they do settle is the claim that believing in God requires abandoning reason. Zack Duncan’s two questions make that point plainly, and the fact that highly trained minds have gone both directions – into faith and out of it – should keep any of us humble about our own certainty.
Not a Criticism
None of this is meant to be an attack on those who have begun to walk away from the Christian faith due to emotional pain.
I’ve been in a similar place myself.
I know what it’s like to experience life circumstances that influenced my feelings, and ultimately my thinking, about God.
Here are two examples:
- As a child, it seemed God never answered my prayers to let me play sports again. The resulting pain felt deeply isolating and as though I was utterly ignored by God. I eventually came to believe that He was either not real or, at the very least, disinterested in me.
- After profoundly experiencing the love and mercy of God for a sustained period of time as an adult, it seemed the Christian faith finally made sense. For several years I had experiential awareness of His goodness and love that lined up with everything the Bible said about God as a Good Father. But then, it suddenly seemed like God had disappeared. I was left in spiritual darkness and heaviness. Once again, it felt like I had been utterly abandoned by Him. The God I had finally come to know as full of love and mercy, had seemingly departed. Was He punishing me? Was He angry? I wasn’t sure. But I knew it felt horrible. And it felt like He had betrayed me and was not trustworthy.
In both situations, my feelings about my circumstances were what drove my initial thinking about God.
Yet in both situations God eventually corrected my thinking.
In the first situation, I finally came to fully believe that the God of the Bible was real without doubt or qualification. In part, I think that’s why the second situation was so much more difficult than the first. All of my senses said that He was either not real or He had utterly cast me off. It seemed that I needed to fight to remember that God was real. I knew He was, even if I was utterly confused by Him.
As I slowly rebuilt on that true foundation of His objective reality, I eventually added other things that I knew to be true of God.
For many months I fought to pray this simple prayer of remembrance:
God, You are real. You are good. You love people. You love me.
It didn’t feel real for a long time.
And eventually He showed me that the pain and suffering were times He could use for my good. He showed me He had been there the whole time in the darkness. He showed me that He was more trustworthy than I had ever imagined. And He showed me that He is far greater than my circumstances.
I am grateful for His grace and mercy.
And I feel deeply for those whose circumstances have lead them away from God.
I see comments like this one below and I imagine a person who perhaps had a truly authentic encounter with God in the past. But when those earlier positive circumstances changed, the view of the truth adjusted to align with the new circumstances.

The way forward is to seek and cling to the truth, regardless of what external circumstances say. But that’s hard to do in times of suffering.
It can especially difficult for those who have experienced pain from fellow Christians.
Because when those negative feelings originate in the church, how much easier is it to ascribe correspondingly negative thoughts to God?
Religious Pain and What Jesus Says About It
There are too many examples of the Christian community not living anything like the standard Jesus calls us to.
There are extreme examples:
- Like the 1994 Rwandan Genocide of Christians when many clergy failed to condemn state sponsored violence against the Tutsi ethnic minority.²
- And the systemic concealment of child sexual abuse within the Roman Catholic Church prioritized the reputation of the institution over innocent children.³
- The extreme pro-war posture of the Russian Orthodox Church in the Russia-Ukraine War, including defrocking priests who have the audacity to pray for peace.⁴
There are also countless “everyday” examples related to gossip, deception, hypocrisy, and the use of coercive spiritual power.
This all leads to suffering, confusion, and brokenness.
The sad irony about church pain leading to rejecting Christianity is that Jesus Himself was received by the hurt and the suffering and the meek.
He lifted up those who are suffering and gave them new life in Him.
Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted. Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth. (Matthew 5:3-5)
And He reserved his harshest words for those who displayed performative religiosity without a humble and changed heart.
They tie up heavy, cumbersome loads and put them on other people's shoulders, but they themselves are not willing to lift a finger to move them. Everything they do is done for people to see: They make their phylacteries wide and the tassels on their garments long; they love the place of honor at banquets and the most important seats in the synagogues; they love to be greeted with respect in the marketplaces and to be called 'Rabbi' by others. (Matthew 23:4-7)

What do we do when we see someone outwardly claiming Christ while living as though He’s not there?
I think it includes recognizing that this can be what it looks like when there are imperfect people following a perfect God. We are all works in process and can therefore all act like hypocrites at times. I know I do.
But that’s not all we should do. We should grieve and lament and repent and reform, knowing that Christians are called to carry the Name of Jesus.
And we should grapple with the reality that some church pain can come from people who might play the part of “Christian” but simply never knew Jesus at all. I’m not talking about the undercover satanist, but the person who loves religion but doesn’t love Jesus.
Jesus was clear that such people have no part in Him.
Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You shut the door of the kingdom of heaven in people's faces. You yourselves do not enter, nor will you let those enter who are trying to. (Matthew 23:13)
It’s not our job to determine who is who. But it is a great reminder to look to Jesus first instead of any human claiming to be His representative.
Wrapping Up
If the experience of pain or suffering has led you to believe that God isn’t real or isn’t good or doesn’t actually love you, I invite you to consider if those conclusions are actually true.
The prophet Jonah ran from God. God pursued him, humbled him, and worked a mighty miracle through him.
There are modern people like Alice Cooper who grew up in a Christian home before rejecting the faith, only to later come back to Jesus.

If you’ve deconverted from the Christian faith, it’s not too late to turn back to Jesus.
To start, you don’t need a radical conviction that it’s all true. You just need an open heart and a willingness to grow in trusting the God who loves you so much that He got down from His throne in Heaven and got up on a Cross.
Below in italics is a prayer you can start with. And if you pray that prayer, don’t stop praying.
Take your doubts and your questions to Jesus. Take your pain and your suffering too.
Because Christians can, and will, let you down. But Christ Himself never will.
God, I am uncertain whether You exist and whether you are listening to me now. I have felt let down by You and by people who say they follow You. But I want to know the truth, and I am willing to live according to it. So if you are there, please reveal Yourself to me. Give me grace to have faith that leads to the abundant life promised by Jesus Christ. Amen.
What if Deconstruction Can Be the Beginning of Deeper Faith
Sources and References
1: System 1 and System 2 Thinking: https://thedecisionlab.com/reference-guide/philosophy/system-1-and-system-2-thinking
2: Rwandan genocide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwandan_genocide
3: Dozens of Catholic priests molested hundreds of Rhode Island victims over decades, multiyear investigation reveals: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/dozens-of-catholic-priests-molested-hundreds-of-rhode-island-victims-over-decades-multiyear-investigation-reveals
4: How the Ukraine war is dividing Orthodox Christians: https://theconversation.com/how-the-ukraine-war-is-dividing-orthodox-christians-178319
A Word from the Editor
Jesus never promised that following Him would spare us pain, and He never asked anyone to pretend their wounds were not real. What He did promise is that He is trustworthy even when every circumstance argues otherwise. “Though he slay me, I will hope in him” (Job 13:15) is not a tidy sentiment – it is a decision made in the dark, before the feelings catch up with the truth. If that is where you are today, the prayer Zack Duncan closes with is not a formality. It is a real door, and it is still open.
Salvation – Eternal Life in Less Than 150 Words
Distributed by – BCWorldview.org
Editor Comment: Zack's honest look at the link between emotional pain and intellectual doubt offers a compassionate, clarifying lens for anyone walking alongside someone in deconstruction today.
This article appeared on Medium and is reprinted with modifications and by permission.